Introduction:

Gujarat High Court strikes again, this time holding that providing an adhoc and standard method to value of undivided share of land involved in provision of construction services as invalid and has Para 2 of Notification No 1/2017 – CT (R) to be read down.

Before going into the detailed study of ruling for understanding the hit and miss of the Court in Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt[1],  it is necessary to understand the issue involved, the major arguments by petitioner and revenue and the analysis of High Court. Let us proceed to examine the same. Our analysis on the judgment and way forward is given at the conclusion of this article.

Read more: The Hit and Miss of Gujarat High Court in Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt – 1/3rd Deduction for Transfer...

Introduction:

In our previous article[1], the concept of taxability of management support services (for brevity ‘MSS”) under fee for technical services (for brevity ‘FTS’ or ‘FIS’) clause has been analyzed in detail.

We have concluded that MSS is not taxable under Article 12, since the term ‘managerial’ is not included in the definition of FTS/FIS. However, we cannot conclude the non-taxability of such income only on examining Article 12. The examining of taxation of such income will not be completed without analyzing the taxability of such services under Articles which deals with ‘Other Income’.

Read more: Management Support Services vis-à-vis Other Income – An Analysis on position under Treaties

In this 96^th edition, we bring you detailed articles on certain tax issues, which seemed to be settled but really unsettling the accepted ideology. The article analysing the judgment of Supreme Court in the matter of Northern Operating Systems raises certain important questions which may have a direct impact on the judgment handed over to us by the Supreme Court. The next article is part of the series of various facets of taxability of management support services. In this part, we have analysed the impact of taxability of said services vis-à-vis other income.

The next article is on the judgment of Gujarat High Court in the matter of Munjaal Manishbhai Bhatt, wherein the High Court read down Para 2 of Notification No 11/2017 – CT (R). We have made certain comments which may have an impact on the judgment in the succeeding forums.

I hope that you will have good time reading this edition and please do share your feedback. I will also urge clients to mail us topics or issues on which you want us to deliberate in our future editions, so that we can contribute to the same.

KEY TOPICS

GST

• ANALYSIS ON SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT IN NORTHERN OPERATING SYSTEMS – UPHOLDING RCM ON MANPOWER SUPPLY FOR SECONDMENT EMPLOYEE
• THE HIT AND MISS OF GUJARAT HC IN MUNJAAL MANISHBHAI BHATT

INTERNATIONAL TAX

• MANAGEMENT SUPPORT SERVICES VIS-À-VIS OTHER INCOME – AN ANALYSIS ON POSITION UNDER TREATIES – PART II

Introduction:

The entire country is swayed by the Honourable Supreme Court’s verdict in the matter of Mohit Minerals Private Limited[1]. This is completely unexpected decision after what we have seen in VKC Footsteps India Private Limited. The Supreme Court has struck down the obligation to pay tax under reverse charge mechanism by the importer. Earlier, the Gujarat High Court qua writ petition filed by Mohit Minerals Private Limited[2], has held the notifications bringing the tax under reverse charge mechanism are ultra-vires the law. The said judgment was appealed before the Supreme Court by Revenue, which led to the current judgment. In this write -up, we shall analyse the decision delivered by Supreme Court.

The entire issue is, whether the importer is liable to pay tax on ocean freight services provided by foreign shipping line qua the foreign supplier under the reverse charge mechanism for the CIF contracts? The position under service tax law[3] and the analysis of the decision of Gujarat High Court[4] can be accessed here.

The Supreme Court after listening to the appellant (the Union of India) and the respondent (Mohit Minerals Private Limited) has opined on various issues, which are summarised hereunder:

Read more: Analysis on Supreme Court Judgment in Mohit Minerals – Striking Down the Levy on Ocean Freight